Orthodontics ran on plaster for most of Dr. Falk's career and a good part of mine. You bit into a tray of cold impression material, held still while it set and tried not to gag. Someone in the lab poured plaster into the mould, trimmed the base and wrote your name on it. With the photographs, X-rays and notes, those white models were the record of a case, and forty years of braces on Cooper Foster Park Road made a great many of them. Karen, who assisted and did lab work for decades before she took over the insurance, has poured her share.
I liked those models. You could hold a bite in your hand, turn it over and look at it from the tongue's side. When I taught at the University of Illinois, a good set of models was how a resident learned to see.
Now most of that is a scanner: a small wand, a few minutes, no tray, and a detailed three-dimensional model on the screen before the patient sits up. A 2021 review of nine studies found some benefit for scanning in every one, and a 2023 review in children called its accuracy clinically acceptable.
What changed
The patient sees what I see. We turn the teeth on the screen, zoom in on the tooth that bothers them, and the conversation is better for it. A new scan laid over an old one shows exactly what has moved. Aligners, retainers and some appliances are made straight from the file; one aligner maker's newest software drafts a first plan about fifteen minutes after the scan is sent.
What did not
A scanner records the surfaces of teeth and gums. It cannot see roots or bone, or tell me how a face will grow; the X-ray and the examination still do that. The software will draw any finish you ask it for. Whether the roots and the bone will allow it, and whether it will stay, is a judgement, and it is mine to make. I rework most of the plans a computer drafts, and I would worry about an orthodontist who didn't.
Timing has not changed either. My PhD was in how the face and jaws form, and the question underneath every child's plan is still when. Start too early and a child wears braces longer than needed; start too late and the growth we could have used is gone. A scan of a nine-year-old is a perfect picture of today. Whether today is the day is the same decision it was on plaster.
Nor do teeth move faster. They move at the speed of biology; the gadgets sold to hurry them have not shown a meaningful benefit in independent reviews.
So: no more goop, better pictures, a better conversation across the desk. The thinking is what it always was. Some of the finest orthodontics I have seen was planned on plaster.
Dr. O
